Online Reputation Repair and Management: The Ultimate Guide

If your online reputation needs:

A refocusing of content

Repairment

Maintenance

An updating

Management

Then this is the perfect guide for you!

Let’s begin…

First, Let’s Understand Online Reputation

The internet loves to throw around the word “canceled”. Within an hour, a 15-second TikTok video can circle the entire world, and the unlucky person owning the unlucky company is deemed unfit for the business world. Some bounce back, turning their weakness into greatness, and some, simply never recover.

But, while social media tends to move on quickly to the next breaking exposé, Google never forgets. Instagram might not be filled with all the juicy details anymore, but one Google search of your name and the whole first page is about that misunderstanding you couldn’t shake off.

An individual building a digital footprint can easily become entangled in the vicious cycle of “cancel culture” and “problematic” behavior. One can turn from a business person to an enemy of society overnight.

In all seriousness though, what does it mean to be canceled? Or rather, what is an online reputation and why is it important?

Online reputation includes every detail the internet converges when seeing your name. Ideally, the first results would be your achievements, captivating news, and a display of your core values. However, when a reputation is left unmanaged, results can deviate and reside in unnecessary, overly personal, and even scandalous topics.

A positive online reputation isn’t only a tool to display what you bring to the table but is also your way of controlling your own narrative, and separating your personal and professional life; the power must be and remain in your hands, to make and shape who you are and how you present yourself on the internet.

Your online reputation is an invaluable first impression as it is often the first encounter you will have with business partners, or clients. Although you can’t see them, they can see you and your entire professional history. That’s why managing your reputation is an integral part of managing your business; it is the entrance to your home.

Part 1- Immediate post-crisis action

1. Finding a specialist:

Reputation management isn’t really a skill you’re born with. Understanding the importance of an online presence is one thing, but knowing how to manage it is another. On the one hand, attacking back or being overly defensive could lead to an immediate souring of your reputation and at times to a rapid downfall of a career.

On the other hand, an online crisis must be handled immediately yet gently and with the right cautionary steps. An unaddressed crisis gives the internet free rein on your online image, flooding the results with misunderstandings and rumors. To avoid further disaster, it’s recommended that you invest in hiring a professional in the field of online reputation and digital footprint, who can take charge of the matter at hand.

How to find a reputation specialist by Percepto

How to find a specialist

 

Advice from the industry
Reputation failure is not a new phenomenon. Every company has its public hiccups. It does often take a major crisis for a company to reach the conclusion that having a reputation specialist on board is an important addition, and then go through their own process of locating the right one.

While it isn’t necessarily the right decision to go to the same specialist as another company, by exploring their journey and learning from their experience, you can decide the best course of action for you.

Review websites
A good specialist has good reviews. There are plenty of sites out there that list all of the positives and negatives of a company and they’re 100% worth taking a look at.

Talk to suppliers
From one company to another, your suppliers should be trustworthy, reliable, and professional. Especially under pressure, it is never a bad idea to receive another perspective and advice.

And hey, if you’re already here, you can always talk to us.

2. Online and Offline Monitoring:

Once you’ve found the right specialist for you, they will usually begin with online monitoring, as this is where the news hits first. Social media channels will be monitored, and online content by your company (and about your company) must be reviewed regularly, to assess the nature of the public’s response. The specialist will evaluate the performance of your company online and then create a work plan.

In order to gain control of the crisis, the specialist will ensure that all the company’s departments are synchronized and are aware of the issue at hand and how to address it. Every department should know its role in the rehabilitation process. When the company is coordinated, further mistakes can be avoided and the repair process would be easier and smoother.

Online Monitoring Levels by Percepto

<h4 “>

Recommended online monitoring aid

(Ranked by value: minimal value to high values)

Basic
“Google Alerts” and similar tools are completely free and will do a fairly good job at monitoring the basics. Simply add all brand-related searches and the name of company executives (such as the CEO) to follow all new information that pops up.

Medium
Online monitoring tools have been created specifically for this purpose. Some of them require payment, but have different payment plans for different use cases and pockets. These could be much more useful for companies in crisis, but also as a way to keep your brand out of harm’s way. “Mention.com” and “Brand24” are great sites to start with as they offer a variety of services and monitoring techniques. There are also new tools that monitor GenAI Tools such as ChatGPT, Perplexity and more, highlighting the importance of optimizing brand visibility in AI-generated search results to ensure your narrative remains accurate across all platforms.

Medium-High
Some suppliers focus on monitoring and alerting their clients to changes in their online perception. This type of supplier could be useful in the aftermath of a serious reputational event, as a first step to assessing the situation and putting out immediate fires. These suppliers are the ultimate partners for times of crises, and some of them . merge offline and online monitoring; The biggest advantage is their ability to adapt to your company, demands, and style. On this level of monitoring, most suppliers do not apply any proactive means and do not interact with social media, employees, and audiences.

High
The ultimate solution for your online reputation issues is a company that does full-service ORM. Such companies take the results of the aforementioned online monitoring and craft them into an operable strategy that spans more than just the aftermath of a crisis. With all-encompassing ORM, you should be willing to invest in the improvement and maintenance of your online reputation; in turn of a topical solution, you will get a strategy that would carry you through many years of market twists and turns and changing social environments.

3. Target Audience

After your company has synchronized its steps and has gauged public perception, it’s time to determine your target audiences. In the event of a crisis, a company’s duty is to recognize all stakeholders who could have been affected. Many unexpected parties within a company and outside of it could feel the impact of a crisis, and it is crucial to pay attention to questions and concerns that may arise.

Take the famous fast food chain “Chipotle” as an example. During 2015-2017, chipotle suffered a tremendous downfall in its social and public image. Multiple viruses kept attacking company employees and spreading to customers. Naturally, the company lost thousands of customers and was on its way to collapse. Shockingly, by the end of 2017, the company made a full recovery and has been flourishing ever since.

So, how was it done?
One main component: Accountability. The company took accountability, while recognizing all stakeholders: those at fault were fired, customers received free food and compensation, employees received new health regulations, health inspectors were hired, and most importantly, every store that hinted at an outbreak was immediately shut down. By doing this, Chipotle showed incredible initiative to take control of the situation, and a genuine concern for the health of its customers.

4. Primary Platforms and Strategies (most important platforms for your company)

Every company has its primary platforms, where its stakeholders are most likely to hang out and consume their content. . A company must first recognize its impact on each platform and thus assess the potential effects . According to this assessment, you can determine which platforms are more crucial for your business to be regularly active on, and focus on bringing forward yourself and your company’s presence there. Prioritize those platforms over others and find out how to be especially active and prominent on them.

Keeping your target audience and primary platforms in mind, it’s time to come up with strategies. While a crucial step, reaching out to stakeholders with your side of the story and confronting the issue can become messy and confusing. Sitting down to think of strategies for each one of the target audiences will create a clear and personal insight, rather than an attempt to make a quick and seemingly sloppy escape. It’s important to dedicate your time to the people you want to reach and to calm the nerves circulating the company.

5. Addressing the Issue

Finally, if you’ve followed the aforementioned steps, your company should be ready to create a proper representation of its response, tailored for  each of the primary platforms and audiences. These communications  should be personalized, sensitive, and inclusive, addressing all that has been done and will be done moving forward. 

Don’t be afraid to be open and  honest, and accept responsibility for the issue at hand.  People easily sniff out hypocrisy. Do not leave room for the internet to put words in your mouth; create a clear, concise narrative that will stay on those platforms for future inquiries. This is the way to start repairing your company’s reputation.

Now, breathe

Company crises do not pick and choose: Companies of all sizes and merit suffer from sudden reputation failures. Now that you’ve taken immediate action, it’s time to work on creating a clear, strong base for your online reputation. It’s important to understand that an online reputation takes time to build. Yes, it can be destroyed in 15 seconds, yes it will take a while to recover. But, and not to get too philosophical here, that’s usually the case with anything valuable – it takes a full year of precision engineering and meticulous crafting to make a single Rolex, but a hammer will smash it to pieces faster than its second hand can tick its last tock.

Consistent activity shouldn’t sacrifice the quality of the content. However, neglecting your online image could lead to a disaster. Google is regularly updating and reshuffling its priorities, meaning any unwanted results that have been suppressed could rear their ugly heads again and reappear. A continuous stream of activity across well-ranked publications considerably reduces the likelihood of negativity jumping to the top results.

Part 2- Repair and Maintain

1. An issue-addressing page

After the issue has been addressed, you might feel the urge to erase the past entirely and create a brand new you. However, this could lead to more future inquiries and problems. Your past controversy shouldn’t be the first introduction on your website, but it should nevertheless take up space, be available and accessible on your website: preferably as a page that includes an explanation and reference to the issue in case anyone wants to read about it. Pages such as FAQ and Q&A allow a space in your online identity to clarify any misunderstanding without unwarranted highlighting.

The W’s that should be included

 
WHAT

Include what course of action the company will be taking moving forward. You can also elaborate on your reasoning

WHY

Tell your story and be sincere. Do not point fingers at anyone. Provide multiple external resources and links related to the issue to allow people to assess the situation.

WHO

Address and acknowledge all who were affected

WHERE

Share where the company has changed and learned from the issue, and where the company will be going forward.

WHEN

Make sure timelines are clear, and that the issue is no longer an active one. It should remain clear when the issue happened and when it was addressed so in case the problem resurfaces, there are no misunderstandings as to the time and place.

2. Re-evaluation

Change demands acknowledgment and growth. The internet is a sensitive, reactionary realm, with an ever-present danger of instantaneous changes and shift of opinions. After a crisis, a company’s brand may be shaky and require updating. Re-evaluating your brand is a way to achieve an honest acknowledgment of the crisis. Ultimately, it helps refocus and reshape the company’s permanent digital image by creating a fresh message synchronized with relevant, up-to-date delivery.

Questions to ask yourself while reevaluating

  • What went wrong?
  • Where were the holes in your strategy that allowed this problem to occur?
  • Was the message wrong?
  • Did you conduct a risk assessment meeting?
  • What actions were taken and how effective were they?

3. Redefining

After re-evaluating, you want to redefine and shift your audience’s focus away from negative past occurrences. You should be able to show your willingness for change and improvement, jump on brand-relevant trends, and begin new projects. This could propel your brand to a broader target audience and generate new ideas and directions.

Key components to redefining

  • Highlight the positives of your brand; find different aspects that wouldn’t be reminiscent of the problem.
  • There is no need to change the company entirely, the goal is to refocus.
  • Change the messaging to show growth while still keeping the company’s integrity and core values.
  • Consider coming up with a new tagline and updating the logo slightly.
  • Roll out all the changes across your website and social media, even if they aren’t on the products yet.
  • Publicly acknowledge the reason for these changes, so they’re not viewed as your brand trying to erase or escape its past.

4. Next Step Monitoring

A company must continuously monitor its online presence to ensure a secure and dependable one. At this point the specialist once again makes sure all the departments are caught up on recent changes and the steps taken to maintain the company’s online presence. In addition, all platforms and forums should be checked regularly to maintain a steadfast awareness of audience feedback, comments, and reactions.

How to monitor

  • Be active on social media
  • Answer important questions that arise
  • Start conversations on Reddit, Quora, etc…
  • Try to cover all areas with knowledge gaps
  • Follow hashtags regarding your brand
  • Make sure you are aware of trends and engage with them (both positive and negative)
  • Direct customers to your issue-addressing page

5. Preparing for future crises

How to future proof your reputation by Percepto

Last but not least, be proactive; even if your reputation repairing process was successful, expect problems and criticism as a way of creating premeditated solutions and keeping your cool. Think ahead of the internet’s demands and be aware of the ever-changing standards. Do your best when the unexpected occurs; learn from your mistakes and the curveballs the internet may throw at you. Every activity has some potential risk and these should always be considered before action is taken

When an online reputation is well-controlled and active through a website, a blog, positive articles, and social media, negativity can be  disputed more easily and eventually disappear behind the latest content, creating a level of insurance for bumps down the line.

Good Job

You’ve successfully read through this reputation repair and management guidebook.

Remember that the Internet is a huge archive and any past mistakes have a good chance of resurfacing. Now, you know to be prepared with a bank of solutions to which the anger can be directed and resolved. Continue monitoring and learning: you’ll be ready next time.

Now we’d like to hear from your experience: was this guide helpful? Did we miss anything?

Scroll to Top